« "SAVE US!"--A Gay Iranian Who Married His Partner Begs for Help from the West | Main | GAY POLAND PROTESTS OFFICIAL GAY-BASHING »
November 26, 2005
PIERRE SEEL, Last Living "Pink Triangle" in France, Dies
Pierre Seel, the last known surviving French homosexual victim of the Nazi concentration camps, has died at the age of 82, it was announced in Paris yesterday. Anyone who has seen the remarkable documentary "Paragraph 175," by Rob Epstein and Jeffrey Friedman -- about the Pink Triangles, the homosexual victims of Nazi repression -- will remember the unforgettable sequence in the film in which Pierre Seel (above left) recounted his arrest and torture for being gay -- this included his multiple rapes, and being sodomized with a wooden stake, which left his ass bleeding all his life long --and how the Nazis fed his lover to be eaten by dogs before his eyes.
When Alsace-Lorraine was annexed by the Germans in 1940, the Nazis systematically began to weed out "anti-social" elements. They directed the French police to establish the notorious "Pink Lists" to keep track of homosexuals, a task the French carried out with enthusiasm. One of their targets was Seel, an Alsatien, who was arrested at the age of 17 -- by Vichy
France's police -- for being homosexual (Vichy France had re-criminalized homosexuality, which had not been illegal since the Code Napoleon; most Vichy legislation was repealed after the war -- but the anti-gay Vichy law remained on the books for four decades until it was finally repealed in 1982.) Seel was turned over to the Nazis, and subsequently sent to the concentration camp of Struthof, the only German concentration camp on French soil during World War II. While in the camp, he discovered that his 18-year-old lover had also been arrested. Seel related that discovery, and the horror that followed it, in his 1994 autobiography, "Moi, Pierre Seel, déporté homosexuel" (cover above right) published by Editions Calmann Levy -- an English editon was published the following year by Basic Books.).Seel wrote:
"All the inmates were summoned to stand at attention in the camp's assembly ground. The camp commandant and all his troops were
there. Into the center of the square we were ordered to form, two SS men dragged a young man. With stupefaction I recognized my beloved, Jo -- he and I hadn't seen each other since a few days before my arrest....The loudspeakers played noisy military music as the SS men stripped him naked, and violently jammed a metal bucket over his head. They unleashed on Jo the camp's ferocious guard-dogs, German Shepherds, who began to rip at his flesh -- first his genitals, and his thighs, and then they devoured Jo before our eyes. His screams of pain were amplified and distorted by the bucket over his head. Frozen in place and trembling, wide-eyed at seeing so much horror, I had tears running down my cheeks. I prayed that he would rapidly lose consciousness...." (My translation from the French edition-- D.I.) Upper left, the sign over the Struthof camp entrance, as it appears today.
After the war, gay concentration camp victims like Seel -- the Pink Triangles, named after the special badge homosexuals in the camps were forced to wear by the Nazis -- were shunned, and refused recognition or compensation from the state like other deportees received. After the war he was allowed back into his family under the condition that he never reveal the true circumstances of his arrest. He went into a downward spiral, entering a marriage of convenience and eventually becoming suicidal -- until deciding to take a stand and make his story public. Then, for the rest of his life, Seel fought for official recognition of the Vichy-Nazi deportation of homosexuals by the French authorities. Seel not only brought his witness before the public on many occasions, but he also fought for the inclusion of the representatives of gay
organizations in the annual French ceremonies commemorating Nazi deportations of Jews, resistants, political prisoners, and others. In 2003, Seel (right) finally received official recognition as a victim of the Holocaust by the International Organization for Migration's program for aiding Nazi victims. But Seel said that, for as long as he would not be recognized by the French state as having been "deported for homosexuality," he considered himself a stateless person. That official recognition of Seel by the French government never came.
After his memoir was published, and following a TV appearance with other deportees, Seel -- a small, frail man then in his 70s --was assaulted and beaten in the streets by a group of young people shouting "dirty faggot." What shocked Seel the most, he said afterwards, was that those who attacked him were not skinheads, but jeunes bourgeois in coats and ties.
Seel will be buried November 28 in the cemetery of Brames, in the Lot-et-Garonne department of France.
The United States Holocaust Memorial Museum in Washington, D.C. has an exhibit dedicated to the homosexual victims of the Nazis -- you can visit an online version of this exhibit by clicking here.
Posted by Doug Ireland at 09:05 AM | Permalink
TrackBack
TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00d8341c0c4453ef00d83497996869e2
Listed below are links to weblogs that reference PIERRE SEEL, Last Living "Pink Triangle" in France, Dies:
Comments
If you need (or want) a computer that’s easy to take along,you can see it from http://www.adapterlist.com/mitac/minote-8090.htm mitac minote 8090 battery whcih offer the longlife and consistently reliable performance you need to get the most out of your notebook .
Posted by: laptop bettery | Mar 6, 2009 1:28:06 AM
http://www.batteryfast.co.uk/mitac/minote-8090.htm mitac minote 8090 battery,
Posted by: battery | Nov 2, 2008 1:52:28 AM
http://www.batteryfast.com/asus/a2500h.htm asus a2500h battery,
Posted by: laptop battery | Oct 12, 2008 10:20:09 PM
Its extremely dissapointing (once again) that the French government and perhaps society refuses to accept Seel's reasons. French society claims to base her democracy from values of 1789 uet like other democracies, this is just a flaw ; or perhaps it excludes various persons [like homosexuals, black people etc]. Then again the French government is represented in most other governments around the world and its going to take a while for gay rights to be fully recognised.
Posted by: Daniel | Jan 10, 2007 3:59:50 PM
http://www.elztq.cn
http://www.china-ztq.cn
http://www.ztqbk.cn
http://www.china-hearingaid.com
http://www.china-hearingaid.cn
http://www.china-hearing.com.cn
http://www.china-ztq.com.cn
http://www.china-starkey.com
http://www.china-oticon.com
http://www.china-resound.com
http://www.china-price.cn
http://www.beijing-hearing.com
http://www.china-deafchild.cn
http://www.51ztq.com.cn
http://www.china-deaf.com
http://www.china-hearing.com
http://www.ztq.com.cn
http://www.china-hearing.cn
http://www.hearingaid.cn
http://www.china-deaf.cn
http://www.china-siemens.com
http://www.undeaf.cn
http://www.china-phonak.com
http://www.gzztq.com
http://www.gdztq.com
http://www.spe-edu.cn
http://www.yipin-hearing.com
http://www.hearinggx.com
http://www.siemens-hearingaid.net
http://www.hearingjs.com
http://www.phonak-hearing.net
http://www.oticon-hearing.com
http://www.nxear.com
http://www.zjhearing.com
http://www.oticon-hearing.net
http://www.ztqnet.cn
http://www.e-hearing.net
http://www.e-ztq.cn
http://www.ztqnet.net
http://www.ztqcom.cn
http://www.ztqnet.com
http://www.orientalcreation.com.cn
http://www.orientalcreation.com.cn/cn
http://www.tjrnzc.com
http://www.bjhuanbao.com.cn
http://www.bjhuanbao.com.cn
http://www.yishenyuan.com
http://www.bzshiji.com
http://www.bzshiji.com/Extend_Site.asp
http://www.bozhongsj.com
Posted by: ds | Oct 25, 2006 6:05:48 AM
"First they came for the Jews. I was silent. I was not a Jew. Then they came for the Communists. I was silent. I was not a Communist. Then they came for the trade unionists. I was silent. I was not a trade unionist. Then they came for me. There was no one left to speak for me." Pastor Martin Niemoller
Why do you need to support Gay rights if you are not Gay? This is why. Why do you need to support anyone's rights? This is why.
Posted by: Meowomon | Dec 2, 2005 2:40:09 PM
I think it could happen again..what happened to Pierre and Jo..and it could happen anywhere
Posted by: Phill | Dec 1, 2005 6:33:15 PM
Reply to Philip Davidson:
Your ignorance of the French language is showing.
The insult "sale pede" in French is accurately translated as "dirty faggot."
Posted by: Doug Ireland | Nov 30, 2005 5:28:44 AM
the French have taken to using American slang dirty "faggot"
since when?
Faggot doesn't even translate
in most of Britain.
Who is this old-fashioned propaganda for?
Posted by: Philip Davidson | Nov 30, 2005 4:21:56 AM
Americanistehsuck, just wondering, are you the last surviving SS officer alive from that camp?
Posted by: Archbishop Bruce J. Simpson | Nov 29, 2005 11:48:14 PM
Thank you,once more, for shining a light in the Darkness. I too,hope and yes pray that Pierre is/will be re-united with his murdered beloved. Doug, your updates are superb.
Posted by: Patrick | Nov 28, 2005 2:33:25 PM
Death to the Naxi scum who would perpetrate these atrocities
Posted by: JudeaM | Nov 27, 2005 8:38:31 PM
Dear Doug
So many thanks for bringing our attention to this sad news, an era has ended indeed. Gay men and lesbians who suffered at the hands of the Nazis were never recognised as victims nor compensated. More generally, governments are holding back on compensation in the recognition that survivors are dying off.
As a sociologist and a gay man, I was deeply moved by accounts of survival of Seel and others. Those works exemplify a scar on humanity that is rarely discussed in 'polite' company.
Today, we should remember Pierre Seel and his generation for all that they have done in transmitting both the horror of the Nazi era but also sharing their stories of life before catastrophe. Oh to have been in pre-war Berlin as a gay man!
I was deeply moved to visit Sachsenhausen concentration camp a few years ago and shuddered to see how (only) fragments of archival material that remain of our past.
As part of the second generation of survivors of Nazi occupation,and a gay man, I feel that our duty is remembrance of that generation who suffered and for those who died for their sexuality. Those who survived the war were later silenced by homophobia and by continued criminalisation of homosexuality.
With best wishes from Dublin Ireland
Sean
Posted by: Sean Reynolds | Nov 27, 2005 12:22:36 PM
Where is French dignity? Where is French honour? Even the mere acknowledgement of the wrongs perpetrated against French homosexuals appears to be beyond French society. How pathetic. All the cheap perfume in the world won't hide the stench of French homophobia.
As for the Germans, reading this story makes me very sorry that it was Hiroshima and Nagasaki that were bombed when there were much more deserving targets in Germany begging the world to destroy the inhumanity that was spawned there.
God bless Pierre Seel. May the Lord have mercy on his soul and on the souls of all those homosexuals who were terrorized by the human filth known as the Nazis.
Posted by: Dave Toronto | Nov 27, 2005 2:43:45 AM
Dear Doug,
here I am seating alone at the counter pissed off and sobbing. Pissed at "my people" who so willingly listened to Charles DeGaulle and claimed victory in 1945 and swept our destructive darkness under the carpet. Pissed at myself too that I knew nothing about Pierre Seel and French homosexual victims of the Nazi concentration camps.
For the 19 years since I have became an American Citizen, I have endured many snooty, self-righteous ex-compatriots (friends & family included) who have derided my country of adoption has being so racist, homophobic, undemocratic, segregationist, etc...
The events of the past month have brought a little smirk to my face, not that I have ill wishes, just that I don't believe the French are any better than the Americans -they are both a pretty rotten bunch, like any other, and both should never forget it.
Best,
Florent
Posted by: florent morellet | Nov 26, 2005 3:27:54 PM
Thank you for posting this story. As much as I knew about the Third Reich, I had never seen this story or read of the further disgusting actions of the SS. I have requested all of my clergy to say Mass for this man this weekend. May his memory live on and the horrors of what man can do to man remain ever fresh.
May God have mercy upon his soul and reunited him with his long lost lover.
+Bruce
Archbishop
Benedictine Order of St. John the Beloved
Posted by: Archbishop Bruce Simpson | Nov 26, 2005 12:15:21 PM