« MOLLY IVINS ON WHY SHE WON'T SUPPORT HILLARY | Main | PETER TATCHELL GETS HIS DUE »

January 27, 2006

A call to solidarity: U.S. GAY GROUPS MUST END THEIR ISOLATIONISM (plus, Sen. Brownback calls gays "fruits")

I wrote the following for the new issue of Gay City News, New York's largest gay weekly:

Rainbow_flag_3 All over the globe, gay people are being persecuted, jailed, and even killed for loving differently. Yet the principal national gay organizations in the United States remain largely indifferent to their fate.

Within the last weeks, there has been a spate of bad news from abroad. Consider: In the United Kingdom, a 28-year-old gay Iranian named Javad—whose full name is not used to protect him and his family in Iran—has been ordered to be deported back to the Islamic Republic of Iran. Last year, a video of Javad and his partner at a private gay party fell into the hands of the police. Fearful of being imprisoned, tortured, and executed for being gay—like so many other Iranian same-sexers—Javad fled to the U.K. last September, winding up in the town of Oakington, where he filed for asylum.

The Persian Gay and Lesbian Organization—PGLO, the largest Iranian gay group withPglo_logo_3  secretariats in several countries, including Turkey and Norway—reported last week: “After a few days, Javad was arrested and taken to Oakington’s police department in Cambridge, where he was threatened and told that if he couldn’t come up with satisfactory answers for their questions they will forcefully deport him, sending him back to Iran. In December the British government denied his refugee status. Under the law, Javad has the right to appeal this decision. Sadly, a few days ago, without taking into consideration his appeal over the ruling, he received papers stating that he must leave the country; therefore, Javad was deprived of any protection by the British government.”

In other words, Tony Blair’s government is sending a victim of Iran’s lethal anti-gay pogrom back into the fiery furnace stoked by the anti-gay hate of the ayatollahs, where at least a dozen gay men have been hanged since last July for how they love, and hundreds more jailed and brutalized by the sex police.

But has there been any word of protest from the Human Rights Campaign (HRC), the National Gay and Lesbian Task Force (NGLTF), or the U.S.-based International Gay and Lesbian Human Rights Commission (IGLRHC) against this inhuman deportation?

Not a peep.

Samba_2 In India—the world’s second most populous country, with 1.1 billion people—homosexuality was accepted in cultural traditions for thousands of years, and the Hindu religion had venerated bisexual gods—including Samba (above left), son of Krishna, who seduced both men and women. Male worshippers had ritual sex with male prostitutes in Hindu temples well into the 20th century.

But homosexuality was made illegal under British colonial rule in the 19th century, and that colonial anti-sodomy law remains on the books, five decades after India’s independence. (The British themselves decriminalized homosexuality in 1968.) Under Indian law, gay sex is bracketed with sex with animals and pedophilia as an “unnatural” offense, punishable by 10 years imprisonment.

In January, in the Indian city of Lucknow—ruled by the ultra-homophobic Samajwadi Party—police arrested four gay men who were having a picnic in a public place. Police claimed the men belonged to an “international gay club” centered around the Internet Web site guys4men.com, on which gay men can place personals and engage in Internet chat. But, wrote Human Rights Watch, “Reports received by HRW indicate that undercover police, posing as gay on the Web site, entrapped one man, then forced him to call others and arrange a meeting where they were arrested.”

The arrest of the Lucknow Four has given new impetus to the campaign for repeal of Article 337, India’s anti-sodomy law, and generated national and international protests. But from HRC, NGLTF, and IGLHRC, nothing has been heard denouncing their imprisonment.

In Nepal, there is a continuing government and police campaign of what human rights groups on the ground there are calling violent “sexual cleansing” directed at gay people and, most particularly, against the many “metis,” the Nepalese word for theMetis_beating  transgendered. Scores have been arrested and imprisoned, and subjected to brutal police violence. In the latest incident just last month, in the capital of Kathmandu, according to a report from Human Rights Watch, “Four uniformed police from Durbar Marg police station reportedly saw [four metis in the street] and shouted, ‘Metis! Kill them!’ One meti was beaten with a baton on her back; one policeman pulled his gun and pointed it at her, threatening that, ‘These hijras pollute the society and must be cleaned out’" ('Hijra” is also a common term for a transgender person.) The two other metis were also beaten severely.” (Above right, a Nepalese meti shows the result of her beating by police)

Metis_protest Nepal’s only organization fighting for the rights of sexual minorities, the Blue Diamond Society, has its very existence threatened by the government, which has instituted proceedings to have it banned for “advocating homosexual rights.” Blue Diamond’s Web site reports that police have scooped up, jailed, and abused its members. Yet from HRC and NGLTF, no protest against the “sexual cleansing” in Nepal. (Left, Nepalese metis protest the arrest of 39 Blue Diamond Society members; note the sign saying, "Either kill us or let us live free")

IGLHRC managed to issue one press release on Nepal—last August—but there has been not another word since, despite continuing anti-gay and anti-meti police violence and persecution. From HRC and NGLTF, nothing.

In Cameroon, where homosexuality is illegal and punishable by five years in prison, nine gay men have been languishing in jail for six months for the crime of being gay. In Ldatdvia_gay_pride_arrests the Baltic countries of Estonia and Latvia, discrimination against gays is about to be set in concrete in their constitutions by adding bans on gay marriage. Gay pride parades are banned, and gays are being brutalized in the streets—while leading politicians are demanding that homosexuality be re-criminalized. (Left, Latvian police break up Gay Pride march in July, 2005)

In Poland recently, under its new ultra-homophobic government, police in Poznan violently attacked a gay rights march and arrested 67 marchers -- causing a huge outcry and demonstrations from European gay groups and a debate in the Europarliament at Strasbourg. Yet in none of these cases I've mentioned above has their been any sort of meaningful response or protest from American gays and lesbians and the institutions that claim to speak for them

Yes, we still have a long way to go in our own country to secure full human rights and equality for all gay people. However, in much of America, gay people are decidedly fortunate in their hard-won freedom compared to our struggling, persecuted peers not only in the countries cited above, but in other lands that there’s not space here to mention.

But HRC and its self-congratulatory closet activists are too busy preparing yet another pricey black-tie fundraising gala in New York—this one honoring Ang Lee and Jake Gyllenhaal of “Brokeback Mountain”—to bother with foreign queers. NGLTF is supposed to be the more “progressive” of the two national gay rights groups—yet a check of its Web site shows that, in the last 13 months, the group has not issued even one single press release on the plight of persecuted gay people abroad.

I’m angry at our Brokebrain gay leaders for not making international solidarity with persecuted gays abroad part of their agenda, and thus part of our national gay agenda. And doing so requires a helluva lot more than just issuing an occasional press release. It requires, yes, real activism, organizing and education. The next time you think of sending a check to HRC or NGLTF, tell them you’re sick at heart at their indifference to this global gay suffering. Demand that they create an international desk, and assign at least one full-time staff person to monitor attacks on gay people in other countries and educate gay Americans about these threats to human freedom abroad.

Demand that these groups immediately take up the most urgent case—the ongoing and massive entrapment, persecution, torture, and execution of gays in the Islamic Republic of Iran, on which their silence has been deafening. Demand they give Iran full-throated attention, through demonstrations—like the ones European gay organizations have been holding repeatedly all across the Continent—public forums, and their own publications. Demand they provide concrete and material help for the penniless gay Iranian refugees from torture who are living precariously from day to day, under constant threat of deportation back to certain persecution for how and whom they love.

The lives of people whose only crime is that they’re like us are at stake. And Iran_tidmus_poster_1_stop_killing_2 remember: if you’re not part of the solution, you’re part of the problem.

If you don’t want to wait for our national gay groups to get off their backsides on the Iran gay crisis, contact the PGLO through its English-language website, pglo.org -- D.I.

For background on the new wave of anti-gay repression in Iran, see my previous articles: July 21 -- Iran Executes Two Gay Teenagers (Updated); August 11 -- Iran Sources Question Rape Charges in Teen Executions; August 12 -- Two New Gay Executions Scheduled in Iran, Says Iranian Exile Group; August 17 -- Iran's Deadly Anti-Gay Crackdown: With Two More Executions Scheduled, the Pace of Repression Steps Up.August 25 -- Iran's Anti-Gay Purge Grows: Reports of New Executions. September 8 -- Iran and the Death of Gay Activism. September 20 -- "They'll Kill Me" -- A Gay Iranian Torture Victim Speaks of His Ordeal ; September 29 -- Iranian Gays Urgently Appeal for Help ; October 6 -- Canada Introduces UN Resolution Condemning Iran's Human Rights Record; November 24, "Save Us"-- A Gay Iranian Who Married His Partner Begs for Help from the West ; January 12, 2006, "Kidnapped: Anopther Gay Iranian Torture Victim Speaks".....Also, don't miss Rob Anderson's excellent article in the November 10 New Republic, "How America's Gay Rights Establishment is Failing Gay Iranians."

"GOD'S SENATOR," SAM BROWNBACK, CALLS GAYS "FRUITS" There's a Sam_brownback Jeff_sharletsharp-eyed profile in the new Rolling Stone by the excellent Jeff Sharlet (left) -- who is the editor of one of my must-reads, The Revealer, the daily review of religion and the press -- of Senator Sam Brownback, "God's Senator," Brownback (right), a Catholic convert from Kansas who's on the hustings in pursuit of the 2008 Republican presidential nomination, once said he wanted to be "the next Jesse Helms," as Sharlet reports. But Sharlet's terrific Rolling Stone piece has stirred up a hornet's nest of gay groups, reports 365gay.com today, because when Sharlett John_marble interviewed Brownback the Senator referred to gay people as "fruits." For example, National Stonewal Democrats' John Marble (at left -- 365gay.com should learn to spell his name right) says, ""Senator Brownback's childish comment only reveals the immaturity of his political policies, and how unqualified he is to represent the people of  Kansas. In 2006, a kid running for president of his high school class wouldn't even call someone that name, let alone a Republican who is being suggested as a candidate for President of the United States." Brownback is the sponsor in the Senate of the proposed Federal Marriage Amendment that would prevent gay and lesbian couples from marrying -- and, as Raw Story reports, the Republicans intend to make gay marriage a hot-button issue once again, in this year's mid-term Congressional elections. To find out what this gay-slagging Senator is all about, read Jeff Sharlet's not-to-be-missed Rolling Stone profileof him by clicking here.

GAY IMMIGRANTS AND THEIR PARTNERS FACE HOSTILITY In the latest issue of Immigrants' Weekly, there's a useful look at how Immigranats_weekly "Individuals who are in gay or lesbian relationships face difficulties in staying together when coming to the US either as immigrants or nonimmigrants.," as Gregory Siskind'sPink_broad_cover  article, "Immigration Options for Gay, Lesbian, and Transsexual Individuals,"  puts it -- read the article by clicking here...... And, in The Pink Broad, the Sydney, Australia-based gay paper (right) that runs many of my articles, there is a report by its editor, Geoffrey Williams, on "The Federal Government’s refusal to issue the documents necessary for Australians to enter into same-sex marriages overseas," which you can read by clicking here.

.

Posted by Doug Ireland at 04:52 PM | Permalink

TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00d8341c0c4453ef00d8345f78e569e2

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference A call to solidarity: U.S. GAY GROUPS MUST END THEIR ISOLATIONISM (plus, Sen. Brownback calls gays "fruits"):

» auto loan from auto loan
auto loan [Read More]

Tracked on May 21, 2006 5:45:16 PM

» http://loan.strangled.net from equity loan
Loans Home Equity Loans - Home Mortgage Student Loans [Read More]

Tracked on May 30, 2006 6:41:02 PM

» Hollywood Creative Directory from Directory Online
Contact information for the film, television and new media industries. [Read More]

Tracked on Jun 2, 2006 5:57:37 AM

» Mozilla Firefox - Smart Keywords from Keyword services for professional search engine optimization
Smart Keywords are an easy way to search websites right from the Location bar. ... Smart Keywords screenshot 2 Visit the page that has the search field that ... [Read More]

Tracked on Jun 2, 2006 3:12:15 PM

» PRESS: Russia's VimpelCom bids for 90% in Armenia's ArmenTel from Russia?s second
-- Russia?s second largest mobile operator VimpelCom has filed a bid to [Read More]

Tracked on Jun 9, 2006 4:33:28 AM

» Iranians Exploit Samarra Bombing from this country
Parviz Davoudi ( IRNA ) "A number of uncivilized and bloodthirsty people who have no regard for humanity think they [Read More]

Tracked on Jun 12, 2006 1:25:27 AM

» Lopresti: Miami Is Hosting No Party for the Pistons from did to the Pistons
Detroit Pistons are in trouble, but before we get to why, let's begin with where. [Read More]

Tracked on Jun 13, 2006 5:37:02 AM

» First cervical cancer vaccine wins US approval from vaccine to prevent
(Reuters) - The first vaccine to prevent cervical cancer won U.S. approval on Thursday, a step welcomed as a major [Read More]

Tracked on Jun 14, 2006 1:20:40 AM

» DeLay leaves Congress with defense of partisanship (Reuters) from Reuters - Fallen
Thursday with a ringing defense of conservatism and his no-holds barred brand of partisanship. [Read More]

Tracked on Jun 15, 2006 5:39:10 PM

» Mourning's Career Finally on a Title Track from back with his
Back in the locker room, with ice packs on his knees and a towel draped over his lap, Mourning leaned back [Read More]

Tracked on Jun 17, 2006 4:57:27 PM

» Seniors Moving Out of Nursing Home System from edicaid waiver
edicaid waiver system easing New York state seniors out of nursing homes [Read More]

Tracked on Jun 19, 2006 12:10:29 AM

» Project Save Seamonkey Lifts Off with First Meeting from The project seems
discussing statistical analysis of remaining bugs in Seamonkey, and finding and designating volunteers [Read More]

Tracked on Jun 30, 2006 3:29:27 AM

» China sets stiffer penalties for graft, accidents from meeting at which
very existence and anti-graft campaigns are expected to heat up in the run-up to the 2007 party congress, a five-yearly [Read More]

Tracked on Jun 30, 2006 10:22:43 PM

» Wall Street Beat: Networking under pressure from and Siemens AG
Call, of $30.7 million. Company shares (ticker symbol: NWRE) fell by $8.41 [Read More]

Tracked on Jul 1, 2006 12:21:41 PM

» N.M. community severely limits water use (AP) from unless a diner
that water isn't provided with restaurant meals unless a diner requests it, and then it's served [Read More]

Tracked on Jul 2, 2006 10:23:56 AM

» Acura announces 2007 American Le Mans Series lineup from of the inevitable
effort, along with Highcroft Racing. Fernandez Racing will mount their HPD/Acura engines in Lola B05/40 chassis and focus [Read More]

Tracked on Jul 24, 2006 1:55:44 PM

» The Most Successful Online Gambling Web Site from Is Illegal in
Gambling Is Illegal in the United States, but That Has Not Stopped Owner Calvin Ayre [Read More]

Tracked on Aug 2, 2006 2:34:55 AM

» Philanthropy Quotations Gift Books Promote Giving from donors. (PRWEB
to charities and their donors. (PRWEB Aug 8, 2006) Trackback URL: http://www.prweb.com/chachingpr.php/UGlnZy1QaWdnLVN1bW0tSW5zZS1JbnNlLVplcm8= [Read More]

Tracked on Aug 10, 2006 3:55:37 AM

» Microcars: Little Cars, Big Savings from a good idea anymore,
car isn't a good idea anymore, you may want to check out some new small cars. They're actually called [Read More]

Tracked on Aug 14, 2006 7:30:24 PM

Comments

http://www.luesterne.com/

Posted by: muschi | Dec 14, 2007 5:41:29 PM

help the homlesshttp://www.smartphonesex.org

Posted by: phone sex | Dec 8, 2007 9:10:19 PM

http://www.phone-sex-psychologist.com
http://www.phone-sex-hypnosis.com
http://www.phonesexhandjobs.org
http://www.smartphonesex.org
http://www.your-account.info
http://www.phone-sex-psychologist.com/phone-sex-student/
http://www.phone-sex-hypnosis.com/subconscious-phone-sex/
http://www.phone-sex-dictionary.com
http://www.wholeearthphonesex.com
http://www.freephonesex.org
http://www.1800phonesex.net
http://www.1on1phonesex.com
http://www.phonesexphone.com
http://www.hotphone.com
http://www.xxx-rated.com
http://phone-sex-blog.blogspot.com
http://phone-sex-escorts.blogspot.com
http://www.blowjobphone.com
http://www.chrissysbedroom.com
http://www.dominatingphonebitches.com
http://www.highclassblondes4phone.com
http://www.livephonedomination.com
http://www.phonefeminization.com
http://www.taboophonefetishes.com
http://www.phone-sex-guestbook.com

Posted by: phone sex | Dec 1, 2007 8:48:04 AM

We are killing the rainforest

Posted by: tire | Oct 17, 2007 6:23:07 AM

Global Warming Isn't A Threat

Posted by: courier | Sep 2, 2007 10:23:39 AM

.

Posted by: Jane | Aug 21, 2007 4:10:20 AM

Hello

Posted by: Hello | Aug 3, 2007 5:43:32 PM

http://www.wholeearthphonesex.com
http://www.phone-sex-psychologist.com
http://www.phone-sex-psychologist.com/phone-sex-student/
http://www.phone-sex-hypnosis.com
http://www.phone-sex-hypnosis.com/subconscious-phone-sex/
http://www.phone-sex-dictionary.com
http://www.phone-sex-dictionary.com/phone-sex-words/
http://www.phone-sex-dictionary.com/phone-sex-words/phone-sex-definitions/
http://www.phone-sex-handjobs.com
http://www.phone-sex-handjobs.com/phone-sex-masturbation/
http://www.phone-sex-handjobs.com/handjob-phone-sex/
http://www.your-account.info
http://www.your-account.info/smart-phone-sex/
http://www.freephonesex.org
http://www.1800phonesex.net
http://www.1on1phonesex.com
http://www.phonesexphone.com
http://www.hotphone.com
http://www.xanga.com/usa_phone_sex
http://www.xanga.com/phone_sex_seeker
http://phone-sex-blog.blogspot.com
http://phone-sex-escorts.blogspot.com
http://www.xxx-rated.com
http://duvx.com/book.php?book=phonesex

Posted by: phone sex | Jul 23, 2007 5:17:54 AM

http://www.wholeearthphonesex.com
http://www.phone-sex-psychologist.com
http://www.phone-sex-psychologist.com/phone-sex-student/
http://www.phone-sex-hypnosis.com
http://www.phone-sex-hypnosis.com/subconscious-phone-sex/
http://www.phone-sex-dictionary.com
http://www.phone-sex-dictionary.com/phone-sex-words/
http://www.phone-sex-dictionary.com/phone-sex-words/phone-sex-definitions/
http://www.phone-sex-handjobs.com
http://www.phone-sex-handjobs.com/phone-sex-masturbation/
http://www.phone-sex-handjobs.com/handjob-phone-sex/
http://www.your-account.info
http://www.your-account.info/smart-phone-sex/
http://www.freephonesex.org
http://www.1800phonesex.net
http://www.1on1phonesex.com
http://www.phonesexphone.com
http://www.hotphone.com
http://www.xanga.com/usa_phone_sex
http://www.xanga.com/phone_sex_seeker
http://phone-sex-blog.blogspot.com
http://phone-sex-escorts.blogspot.com
http://www.xxx-rated.com
http://duvx.com/book.php?book=phonesex

Posted by: phone sex | Jul 23, 2007 5:14:14 AM

http://www.elztq.cn
http://www.china-ztq.cn
http://www.ztqbk.cn
http://www.china-hearingaid.com
http://www.china-hearingaid.cn
http://www.china-hearing.com.cn
http://www.china-ztq.com.cn
http://www.china-starkey.com
http://www.china-oticon.com
http://www.china-resound.com
http://www.china-price.cn
http://www.beijing-hearing.com
http://www.china-deafchild.cn
http://www.51ztq.com.cn
http://www.china-deaf.com
http://www.china-hearing.com
http://www.ztq.com.cn
http://www.china-hearing.cn
http://www.hearingaid.cn
http://www.china-deaf.cn
http://www.china-siemens.com
http://www.undeaf.cn
http://www.china-phonak.com
http://www.gzztq.com
http://www.gdztq.com
http://www.spe-edu.cn
http://www.yipin-hearing.com
http://www.hearinggx.com
http://www.siemens-hearingaid.net
http://www.hearingjs.com
http://www.phonak-hearing.net
http://www.oticon-hearing.com
http://www.nxear.com
http://www.zjhearing.com
http://www.oticon-hearing.net
http://www.ztqnet.cn
http://www.e-hearing.net
http://www.e-ztq.cn
http://www.ztqnet.net
http://www.ztqcom.cn
http://www.ztqnet.com
http://www.orientalcreation.com.cn
http://www.orientalcreation.com.cn/cn
http://www.tjrnzc.com
http://www.bjhuanbao.com.cn
http://www.bjhuanbao.com.cn
http://www.yishenyuan.com
http://www.bzshiji.com
http://www.bzshiji.com/Extend_Site.asp
http://www.bozhongsj.com

Posted by: ds | Oct 25, 2006 5:30:21 AM

ONLY HUMAN: For Gay Palestinians, Tel Aviv Is Mecca
By kathleen peratis
February 24, 2006
Al-Fatiha â?" which calls itself the principal international organization
promoting the rights of lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgender Arabs â?"
is located
not in Beirut or Cairo, but in Washington, D.C. And no wonder: The
international movement for the rights of lesbian, gay, bisexual and
transgender people
hardly exists inside the Muslim world.
Arab human rights organizations sometimes advocate for gay rights, but they
do so sotto voce. In fact, the only country in the Middle East in which gay
people may safely leave the closet is Israel. Which is why, for gay
Palestinians, Tel Aviv is Mecca.
Gay Palestinian men flee to Israel because they are not safe in the West Bank
and Gaza. They also have no place else to go.
"Israel is close and far at the same time," says Haneen Maikey, a gay rights
activist with Jerusalem Open House, one of the principal gay rights
organizations in Israel. If the sexuality of a gay man in Palestine is
exposed, his
family might torture or kill him and the police will turn a blind eye.
Because they are so vulnerable to blackmail, it is assumed by the families
and neighbors of gay Palestinian men â?" sometimes correctly â?" that they
have
been blackmailed into becoming informers, either for Israeli intelligence or
for opposition Palestinian factions. So when they meet a violent end, the
motivation of the killers is not entirely clear.
And in Israel? Misinformation abounds. In a 2004 speech at the University of
California, Berkeley, Alan Dershowitz said: "I support Israel because I
support gay rights. Recently, a progressive congressman, Barney Frank from
Massachusetts, worked with me and Israel to grant asylum for 40
Palestinian gays."
Alas, not a word of this is true.
When gay Palestinian men run for their lives into Israel, they do not seek
â?"
and they cannot get â?" "asylum," which is a special status under
international
law available to those who can establish a "well founded fear of
persecution" in the country of their nationality or "place of habitual
residence."
Israel has never granted asylum to Palestinians, gay or not, says Anat
Ben-Dor of
the Refugee Rights Clinic at the Tel Aviv University Law Faculty â?" even
those
who can credibly claim they will be killed if they are sent back to the West
Bank or Gaza. This is because Israel interprets international asylum law â?"
the 1951 Convention Relating to the Status of Refugees, which Israel has
signed â?" as inapplicable to Palestinian nationals.
The United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees in Jerusalem advises any
Palestinian seeking asylum in Israel that he or she is ineligible to apply.
Nevertheless, in years past, West Bank Palestinians were sometimes allowed
official or unofficial residence in Israel on any one of a number of
humanitarian
grounds. These included family reunification, medical treatment, fear of
persecution or because they were blessed with high-profile friends. But
not any
more.
In 2002, Palestinians with Israeli identity cards issued under family
reunification laws allegedly used that status to aid suicide bombers. The
Nationality and Entry Into Israel Law of 2003 was quickly passed,
effectively revoking
the family reunification laws and sharply limiting the authority of even the
interior minister to grant residency permits to Palestinians.
Several petitions are pending in the Supreme Court in Jerusalem challenging
the law on constitutional grounds, because there is no exception for those
with a well-founded fear of persecution. (There is an exception for
people who
"identify with the State of Israel and its goals" and who "performed a
material act to advance the security" of the state â?" in other words,
collaborators â?"
thus validating the common suspicion among Palestinians.)
The new law, and the new reality, has led to a crackdown on gay Palestinians
in Israel, according to Shaul Gonen, a former board member of The Aguda, the
largest of the Israeli lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgender organizations.
(The few lesbians who flee move more easily under the radar screen, aided by
Aswat, an Israeli-Arab organization for Palestinian lesbians.) Asylum has
always been out of the question, but now, no official status is possible.
So gay Palestinians who make their desperate way to Israel simply hope to
disappear into the gay subculture of Tel Aviv or Haifa. Slipping into
Israel is
still not impossible, though it has gotten harder. But with no money, no
Hebrew, and no employment, they sooner or later come to the attention of the
police, where they are arrested or summarily expelled.
The best hope for the lucky few is unofficial and temporary protection â?"
weeks or a few months â?" while an NGO seeks to arrange asylum in a third
country.
But this is a long shot. In the three years the Refugee Rights Clinic in Tel
Aviv has been operating, they have gotten third-country asylum for a grand
total of three gay Palestinians, admits Ben-Dor.
Gonen estimates that since 1997, when the gay rights organizations started
counting, about 300 gay Palestinian men have come to Israel in the hope of
finding safety. Most came during the Oslo years, and none have official
residence status. About 20, he says, are now under "house arrest" or "area
arrest,"
which is "house arrest" with a little extra latitude. The rest are either in
jail, have been summarily deported to an unknown fate, or are still evading
detection.
So what exactly was Dershowitz talking about? His email reply to my email
query was, "The reference to working with Barney Frank is incorrect. Barney
Frank told [me] the story."
As for Frank: He confessed to being Dershowitz's source, to getting things a
little wrong, and to confusing "house arrest" and "area arrest" with "asylum"
â?" a little like confusing slavery with freedom. Frank did add that he
intended to address these issues with Israeli officials.
Sadly, the activists I spoke to saw no alternative to the modest protection
now afforded by "area arrest," and even suggested that outside pressure might
backfire. In the current climate, Israel is not opening its doors to gay
Palestinians, period. Nothing personal. With more sadness than outrage, the
activists acknowledge that erstwhile Palestinian asylum seekers in Israel are
simply further examples of collateral damage in the ongoing Middle East
tragedy.
Kathleen Peratis, a partner in the New York law firm Outten & Golden, is a
trustee of Human Rights Watch.

Posted by: AJ WEBERMAN | Feb 25, 2006 12:57:44 PM

REPLY TO ROBERT:
You are confusing two cases -- the one to which you refer, which was covered extensively by UK Gay News, has indeed been resolved satisfactorily, but it involved a NORTH AFRICAN refugee, not an IRANIAN. The Javad case of which I wrote is a completely different case from the one to which you refer.

Posted by: Doug Ireland | Feb 1, 2006 8:03:07 AM

Re Nepal: what is the position of the Maoist insurgents on gay rights? The NPA in the Phillipines has embraced the idea, we are told: wasn't you Doug who reported on a gay wedding of two of their members, they celebrated?

Posted by: Paul Lyon | Jan 29, 2006 10:54:56 PM

Dear friends (LGBT)
It is unfortunate when we look at the way the so caled sensible peoples are reacting toward the peoples of the other side of this world. If Gay sex is no unnatural and hetero sex is natural then why there is a law to control the natural sexual behavoiur.Iaslamic fundamentals are fagot who goes by their narrow perception of this world .Why dont u just leave us to leave in the way we are leaving. They are not commiting any crime but only leading a way they want to lead , without disturbing other

mainak

Posted by: mainak | Jan 28, 2006 11:38:50 PM

Senator Bareback is a closet case. The bigger the homophobe, the bigger the closet.

More of these gay-bashing closet cases need to be outed.

And we need to catch Dubya getting a blow job...thats the only way he can be impeached.

Posted by: Tom3 | Jan 28, 2006 1:40:47 PM

Your reference to the Iranian who fled to the UK for asylum, has since been granted permission to stay and he may be registering a civil partnership with his British boyfriend. You need to correct your story.

Robert

Posted by: Robert | Jan 28, 2006 12:40:05 PM

Post a comment